Constantine Christofi (RPC) examines the legal and practical issues.
Question
On review of a decision under TMA 1970 s 49E HMRC’s review officer reduced an assessment imposed on my client by 30%. The original officer then ‘cancelled’ that decision by issuing a fresh assessment for the additional 30% that had been cancelled. Can HMRC override its own statutory review decisions in this way?
Answer
In short no. Statistics (HMRC’s reviews and appeals: 2013/14see bit.ly/3zbz5sA) suggest that statutory reviews can be fruitful for the taxpayer – but only in penalty appeals as opposed to substantive cases that call for an in-depth analysis of a complex technical issue. In the latter case the review officer is unlikely to disagree with HMRC’s original stated position. (Note: all statutory references below are to TMA 1970.)
Recent scrutiny
The robustness of the independent review process came under...
If you or your firm subscribes to Taxjournal.com, please click the login box below:
If you do not subscribe but are a registered user, please enter your details in the following boxes:
Constantine Christofi (RPC) examines the legal and practical issues.
Question
On review of a decision under TMA 1970 s 49E HMRC’s review officer reduced an assessment imposed on my client by 30%. The original officer then ‘cancelled’ that decision by issuing a fresh assessment for the additional 30% that had been cancelled. Can HMRC override its own statutory review decisions in this way?
Answer
In short no. Statistics (HMRC’s reviews and appeals: 2013/14see bit.ly/3zbz5sA) suggest that statutory reviews can be fruitful for the taxpayer – but only in penalty appeals as opposed to substantive cases that call for an in-depth analysis of a complex technical issue. In the latter case the review officer is unlikely to disagree with HMRC’s original stated position. (Note: all statutory references below are to TMA 1970.)
Recent scrutiny
The robustness of the independent review process came under...
If you or your firm subscribes to Taxjournal.com, please click the login box below:
If you do not subscribe but are a registered user, please enter your details in the following boxes:
