Market leading insight for tax experts
View online issue

Promises, promises

printer Mail
How realistic are the Tory leadership candidates’ pledges on tax?

With the country’s tax burden at the highest for 70 years, the eleven Conservative Party leadership candidates have opened their campaigns, leading with pledges around tax.

In a notable slight against the former chancellor, Rishi Sunak, a front-runner to be the next prime minister, the remaining candidates have said that they would reverse Sunak’s measures over the last few years: these include reversing the 1.25% national insurance increase (the health and social care levy), cancelling the planned increase to corporation tax to 25% from April 2023, and one candidate, Penny Mordaunt, offering to increase the basic and higher tax thresholds by inflation.

Rishi Sunak is the obvious outlier in the race, ruling out tax cuts until the public finances improve – a risky leadership campaign strategy from the recently departed at number 11, but he is the closest to the detail of the public finances and suggests the other candidates should heed his warning.

A new prime minister and their chancellor will have a difficult job on their hands: promises of wild tax cuts could be enough for new occupants at Downing Street, but the cost will be eye-watering, with estimates putting the total cost of the candidates’ promises so far at £330bn. Whilst short-term tax cuts will offer some respite to working families combatting the cost of living, the fiscal stimulus will undoubtedly fuel further inflation and do nothing to tackle the nation’s debt which is as much as the size of the UK economy.

When a new prime minister is in place, the reality for them and their chancellor is likely to be very different to the euphoria surrounding the current leadership contest. A fiscally responsible former chancellor may not offer the change the public desires but it may be right for the long-term future of the UK economy. 

CandidateComments on tax
*Kemi Badenoch, former Levelling-up Minister, MP for Saffrod WaldenThe former levelling-up minister supports lower taxes 'to boost growth and productivity' but has been light on the exact detail of her proposals so far.
*Suella Braverman, Attorney General, MP for FarehamThe MP for Fareham has pledged to cut the cost of government to fund a 'radical' and 'rapid' plan to slash taxes.  The attorney general wants to remove VAT from energy bills and reduce corporation tax to attract investment, but hasn't committed to the exact levels.
*Rehman Chishti, MP for Gillingham and RainhamThe MP for Gillingham and Rainham has declared a vision for lower taxes but wouldn't commit to providing specific policy measures without seeing the detail.  Chishti suggested offering tax incentives to workers rather than offering universal cuts to tax rates.
*Jeremy Hunt, MP for South West SurreyA previous Conservative Party leadership contender against Boris Johnson, Jeremy Hunt has focused on supporting business and wants to cut corporation tax to 15% at his first Autumn Budget. The former foreign secretary also set out a plan for a five-year business rates holiday for the most deprived parts of the country. However, Hunt intimated that his tax cutting proposals are predicated on growth saying that an income tax cut has to be 'done in a way which is sustainable'. Hunt is one of the few leadership contenders who has confirmed the 1.25% health and social care levy would remain as the 'NHS needs the money'.
*Sajid Javid, former Health Secretary, MP for BromsgroveThe former chancellor wants to cut fuel duty by 10p within days of becoming prime minister. Javid also pledged to cut income tax by 1p in April 2023, reduce corporation tax by 1p per year until it reaches 15% and cancel the 1.25% health and social care levy (even though this was introduced during his short time as health secretary).
*Penny Mordaunt, Minister of State, MP for Portsmouth NorthThe minister says that 'simply looking at tax rises or cuts is a vast oversimplification of our economic challenges'. Mordaunt, an early favourite amongst Conservative MPs, said she would offer targeted tax cuts by reducing VAT on fuel from 20% to 10%, halt the National Insurance rise (the 1.25% health and social care levy) and cut corporation tax. She would also raise the basic and higher rate tax thresholds by inflation to combat the fiscal drag effect for middle-income working families.
*Grant Shapps, Transport Secretary, MP for Welwyn HatfieldThe transport secretary says he will hold an emergency budget within days of becoming Prime Minister but he has so far only been able to offer an accelerated 1p income tax in April 2023. Shapps says the government cannot put up taxes in the short-term and he would freeze the scheduled increase in corporation tax. He has a vision for lower taxes which would hopefully become clear at his first Budget.
Rishi Sunak, former Chancellor of the Exchequer, MP for Richmond (Yorks)During his time as chancellor, Rishi Sunak was the architect of cutting entrepreneurs' relief from £10m to £1m, freezing tax allowances until April 2026, introducing the 1.25% health and social care levy and increasing corporation tax to 25% from April 2025 - all culminating in the highest tax burden in the country for 70 years. A matter of weeks into his role as chancellor, Sunak put his best foot forward with a £300bn pandemic support package, with his flagship furlough scheme gaining him widespread applause. Since then, Sunak's star has faded and was only able to offer a 5p reduction in fuel duty and aligning the lower earnings limit for NICs to the personal allowance in his last Spring Statement. The fiscally responsible former chancellor stands by his actions and has ruled out any tax cuts until the public finances improve.
Liz Truss, Foreign Secretary, MP for South West NorfolkThe present foreign secretary will cut taxes 'from day one'. Truss says she will cut fuel duty by more than the 5p per litre reduction already in place, reverse the NIC rise, which she says would incentivise job creation, and overhaul business rates. Truss has pledged to 'keep corporation tax competitive so we can attract business and investment into Britain' but hasn't gone as far as confirming that she would cancel the scheduled increase to corporation tax to 25% from April 2023.
*Tom Tugendhat, MP for Tonbridge and MallingTom Tugendhat was early into the leadership contest, and has said he will reverse the NI increase (the 1.25% health and social care levy) and reduce fuel duty. Tugendhat has also claimed the tax system should be used to stimulate investment, and is targeting the research and development tax regime to achieve this strategy. His backers have said that he would be a 'natural tax cutter' if selected as the next prime minister, but Tugendhat himself has warned that tax cuts cannot be the 'only round in the magazine' for boosting the economy.
*Nadhim Zahawi, Chancellor of the Exchequer, MP for Stratford-on-AvonZahawi is currently in the driving seat on the government's tax policy, and the newly appointed chancellor claims that 'nothing is off the table' when cutting taxes for families and businesses. The former education secretary will bring forward the planned 1% cut to the basic rate of income tax to 2023 and have a further 1% cut to 18% from 2024.  Zahawi would cancel the planned corporation tax increase proposed by his predecessor, and abolish VAT and green levies on energy bills for two years.

*Candidates who have since withdrawn/been eliminated from contest

Issue: 1583
Categories: In brief
EDITOR'S PICKstar
Top